Mixed Views on President Samia’s Three Years in Power Amid Controversy Over JPM’s Death

By Adonis Byemelwa

Three years into President Samia Suluhu Hassan's tenure, Tanzania faces a moment of reflection, marked by a flurry of revelations and calls for transparency in governance. Former Chief of Defense Forces General Venance Mabeyo's recent interviews have reignited scrutiny over the events surrounding the passing of her predecessor, the late John Pombe Magufuli. Mabeyo's disclosures, shedding light on the circumstances preceding Magufuli's demise, prompt a deeper examination of Tanzania's political landscape.

The cloak of secrecy surrounding Magufuli's illness and eventual demise prompts scrutiny regarding the transparency of leadership transitions in the country. Renowned journalist Ansbert Ngurumo, currently living in exile in Finland, contends that this veil of secrecy fosters speculation and erodes public confidence. Ngurumo emphasizes the imperative of open communication and accountability in addressing matters of national significance.

The ELCT Karagwe Diocese Bishop, Benson Bagonza, joins the call for the declassification of information related to a leader's illness, death, and succession, echoing sentiments of governance reform and the promotion of democratic principles. Advocates stress the importance of educating the younger generation and preventing the manipulation of information for personal or political gain.

In a lengthy statement posted on his Facebook account, Bishop Bagonza highlights that Mabeyo's revelations underscore the complexities of power dynamics within Tanzania's political elite. His unwavering commitment to revealing the truth, regardless of potential consequences, reflects the underlying tensions and struggles for transparency within the country's corridors of power.

The implications of Mabeyo's disclosures extend beyond the realm of politics, touching on broader societal concerns about accountability and governance. The clamor for truth and transparency resonates with Tanzanians seeking to reconcile the past and chart a path toward a more accountable and inclusive future.

In the face of uncertainty and speculation, President Samia's administration must heed the calls for transparency and accountability, ensuring that the lessons of the past inform the decisions of the present and shape the trajectory of the nation's future. As Tanzania continues its journey toward progress and prosperity, the pursuit of truth and transparency remains paramount in building a stronger and more resilient democracy.

The Chairman of the Chadema Youth Council (Bavicha), John Pambalu, offers insights into President Samia's decision to retain much of Magufuli's cabinet and administration, noting its divisive reception among the populace. While some commend it as a pragmatic move to maintain stability, others criticize it as a missed opportunity for enacting necessary reforms, thus shaping perceptions of her leadership from the outset.

Despite President Samia's initial pledges of reconciliation and a new political direction, Pambalu highlights contradictions between her rhetoric and actions. The pursuit of terrorism charges against opposition figures like Honorable Freeman Mbowe raises doubts about her commitment to democratic values and the rule of law, navigating Tanzania's intricate political landscape while carving out a distinct leadership style.

Pambalu further discusses controversial agreements like the DP World deal aimed at privatizing mainland ports, which stirred public discontent and criticism from various institutions. He underscores concerns about transparency and accountability in government dealings, emphasizing the need for greater oversight and scrutiny of major contracts and agreements under President Samia's administration.

Adding to the discourse, President Samia was once quoted acknowledging the presence of corruption within her government, expressing bewilderment at its extent, akin to a goat munching beyond its tethered rope.

In a shocking revelation, a police officer based in Shinyanga, who spoke on condition of anonymity, has sparked controversy by suggesting that allowing theft from the government may have positive outcomes. The officer contends that President Samia's purported leniency towards corruption creates opportunities for individuals to invest stolen funds locally, thereby stimulating economic activity.

While acknowledging the legality of such actions remains questionable, the officer argues that the circulation of stolen money within the country contributes to job creation and increased purchasing power among citizens. This stark departure from the stringent anti-corruption measures implemented during Magufuli's tenure raises concerns about the government's stance on accountability and integrity.

The officer's remarks shed light on the complex debate surrounding corruption in Tanzania, highlighting divergent perspectives on its economic implications and societal impact. However, critics condemn such views, emphasizing the corrosive effects of corruption on governance, development, and public trust.

 The recent mini reshuffle in local government administration saw President Samia praising the CCM publicity secretary for revealing weaknesses that would be addressed by regional commissioners, district bosses, intelligence systems, and district executive directors. She noted systemic mishandling of people's concerns, warning that this could lead to significant defeats for political leaders in the upcoming general elections.

President Samia emphasized her government's inclusivity, stating that she harbors no camps within her party. She emphasized blending all leaders regardless of their stances, akin to a mother treating her children equally, highlighting her commitment to fostering unity and cooperation within the party and government.

The revelation of rampant corruption within the government under President Samia's watch sparked outrage among Tanzanians. Despite promises to combat corruption, her administration's perceived lack of decisive action and ambiguous statements on the issue fueled skepticism and frustration. The mounting economic challenges, including the soaring cost of living and rising national debt, further eroded public confidence in her leadership.

Pambalu argues that President Samia's administration lacks a clear economic vision, unlike her predecessors who championed specific ideologies or initiatives. The absence of a coherent economic strategy has left many Tanzanians uncertain about the country's economic future, exacerbating concerns about financial stability and long-term prosperity.

In the face of these governance errors and national concerns, President Samia's leadership faces growing scrutiny and criticism. While her tenure has seen some successes, such as the completion of infrastructure projects, they have been overshadowed by systemic challenges and perceived shortcomings in governance.

A retired teacher and pastor from Misenyi District, Gozbert Muganyizi, emphasizes the urgent need for President Samia's administration to prioritize transparency and accountability as Tanzania charts its future course. Muganyizi asserts that the nation's progress hinges on effective leadership, accountable governance, and a steadfast commitment to democratic principles and human rights.

With his years of experience in education and community service, Muganyizi underscores the importance of heeding the voices of Tanzanians demanding meaningful reforms and decisive action. He emphasizes that addressing pressing challenges such as corruption and economic stability requires genuine efforts from the government.

As Tanzania looks to realize its full potential and secure a brighter future for its citizens, Muganyizi calls on President Samia to lead with integrity and vision. Only through transparent and accountable governance can the nation overcome obstacles and pave the way for prosperity and growth.