PAN AFRICAN VISIONSPAN AFRICAN VISIONSPAN AFRICAN VISIONS
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • Politics
    PoliticsShow More
    Mutharika’s First Year: Malawi Has The Kwacha, But Not The Dollars

    A year into Peter Mutharika's second presidency, Malawi's harvest is bigger, inflation…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Gabon and China Forge New Strategic Alliance as Presidents Oligui Nguema and Xi Jinping Seal Six Cooperation Agreements

    By Boris Esono Nwenfor Gabon and China have taken a major step…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Bishop Trevor Mwamba: Zambia’s Moral Voice Caught In A Political Storm

    From the pulpit to the leadership of Kenneth Kaunda’s historic independence party,…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Cleared of Treason, Jailed Anyway: The Shocking Case That Defies Justice and Accountability In Tanzania

    By Adonis Byemelwa Dar es Salaam — For 577 days, Tanzania's government…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Cameroon’s Anglophone Crisis at 10: African Bar Association Demands International Mediation and Justice for Victims

    In resolutions adopted at its September 2026 conference in Cabo Verde and…

    By
    Pan African Visions
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    Mutharika’s First Year: Malawi Has The Kwacha, But Not The Dollars

    A year into Peter Mutharika's second presidency, Malawi's harvest is bigger, inflation…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    CDC: Franklin Njie and the Fight to Rebuild Cameroon’s Agro-Industrial Giant

    By Ngunyi Sonita Nwohtazie* For nearly eight decades, the Cameroon Development Corporation…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Managing U.S. Sanctions, Export Controls, and Trade Compliance Risks In U.S.-Africa Energy Investments

    By Ngosong Fonkem * As Africa Energy Week (“AEW”) 2026 concluded in…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    ENH–Linkar Project Opens Global Doors for Mozambique’s Energy SMEs

    From international partnerships to business training and investment opportunities, the African Development…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    America Cannot Afford to Miss Africa’s Energy Boom- ASAFO’s Jude Kearney

    By Ajong Mbapndah L* Africa's energy sector is entering a defining period,…

    By
    Pan African Visions
  • Health
  • Sport
    SportShow More
    Cameroon Makes Strong Showing in 2026 CAF Awards Nominations

    By Ngunyi Sonita Nwohtazie BUEA, PAV – Cameroon has secured a strong…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Adnan Aziz: The Unfinished Journey of an Ambitious African Footballer

    From Benin to Europe, with Argentina potentially on the horizon, the 24-year-old…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Zambia : Nkana Hit With K100,000 Fine Over Political Chants

    KITWE, Zambia – Zambian football giants Nkana FC have been slapped with…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Paulo J. Cruz On Building Africa’s Next Billion-Dollar Sports Economy

    By Ajong Mbapndah L Africa has no shortage of sporting talent, passionate…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    CAF Abandons Unpopular Four-Year AFCON Plan

    By Boris Esono Nwenfor BUEA, PAV – The Confederation of African Football…

    By
    Pan African Visions
  • Multimedia
    • Sports
    • Documentaries
    • Comedy
    • Music
    • Interviews
  • APO/PAV
  • AMA/PAV
    AMA/PAVShow More
    The Government of Sierra Leone and WFP reaffirm their partnership to provide daily meals to more than 276,000 schoolchildren

    Rome, Italy, 06 November 2026 -/African Media Agency (AMA)/ – The United…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    MTWW Launches in Nigeria to Advance Safer, More Inclusive Trade for Women

    The Making Trade Work for Women (MTWW) project was officially launched in…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    e-Crime Bureau Signs Cybersecurity Partnership with Smart Africa, Reinforcing its Global Expansion

    The partnership, signed on the sidelines of the 15th Africa Internet Governance…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Beira Corridor Forum Calls for Stronger Regional Partnerships to Secure Southern Africa’s Energy Future

    Forum highlights rising regional fuel demand, infrastructure investment and cross-border collaboration as…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Andela, OpenAI and Miva Open University Bring 200 Engineers Together to Build AI-Powered Learning Solutions

    Part of the pan-African Codex Champions Series, the Lagos showcase demonstrates how…

    By
    Pan African Visions
  • Media OutReach
    Media OutReachShow More
    HKUST President Prof. Nancy IP Receives UNESCO–Equatorial Guinea International Prize for Research in Life Sciences

    HONG KONG SAR – Media OutReach Newswire – 7 November 2026 –…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    City Chamber Orchestra of Hong Kong presents NORDIC SEASONS

    21 NOV 2026 (SAT, 8:00pm) Tsuen Wan Town Hall AuditoriumHONG KONG SAR…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Ningbo Consensus on Collaborative Development released at 2026 Global Mayors Dialogue · Ningbo

    NINGBO, CHINA – Media OutReach Newswire – 6 November 2026 – The…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    ZTE Showcases at Hong Kong FinTech Week 2026: Architecting a Digital Foundation for the Era of Agentic Finance with “Zero Failure, Trust, Optimal TCO, and Open Ecosystem”

    ZTE presented its infrastructure strategy for agentic finance at Hong Kong FinTech…

    By
    Pan African Visions
    Beyond the exhibition floor: How robots, AI and networks are moving into the real world

    TONGXIANG, CHINA – Media OutReach Newswire – 6 November 2026 – A…

    By
    Pan African Visions
  • Blogs
    • African Show Biz
    • Insights Africa
    • Cumaland Diary
    • Kamer Blues
    • Nigerian Round Up
    • Ugandan Titbits
    • African View Points
    • Global Africa
  • Magazines
Search
  • Global Africa
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • African Newsmakers
  • African View Points
  • Development
  • Discoveries
  • Education
© 2026. Pan African Visions. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Intellectuals & South Africa’s Quest for Economic Transformation
Font ResizerAa
PAN AFRICAN VISIONSPAN AFRICAN VISIONS
  • Politics
  • Business in Africa
  • Blog
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Multimedia
  • Contact
Search
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Health
  • Sport
  • Multimedia
    • Sports
    • Documentaries
    • Comedy
    • Music
    • Interviews
  • APO/PAV
  • AMA/PAV
  • Media OutReach
  • Blogs
    • African Show Biz
    • Insights Africa
    • Cumaland Diary
    • Kamer Blues
    • Nigerian Round Up
    • Ugandan Titbits
    • African View Points
    • Global Africa
  • Magazines
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2025 Pan African Visions.  All Rights Reserved.
PAN AFRICAN VISIONS > Blog > Africa > SOUTH AFRICA > Intellectuals & South Africa’s Quest for Economic Transformation
BlogsFeaturedGlobal AfricaOpinionSOUTH AFRICA

Intellectuals & South Africa’s Quest for Economic Transformation

Last updated: January 7, 2014 3:20 am
Pan African Visions
Share
SHARE

South African politicians are always challenging their ‘thinkers’ to start discussing issues of national interest while they are still hot on the table. It is said that intellectuals wait until wrong decisions are made and then bounce on them to criticize and condemn. Who has been in default: intellectuals for speaking out after the fact or political leaders for not hearing objections? Regarding economic aspirations for post-apartheid SA, the discussion is not new. Indeed it was triggered in May 1998 by the then country’s Deputy President, Thabo Mbeki, when he stated before Parliament that SA was not a nation; it was two nations rolled into one. A small portion of SA was composed of a handful segment of affluent society that happened to be white. At the other extreme of the spectrum millions of the country’s citizens were locked in abject poverty with no way out. They happened to be black. The statement came to be known as Mbeki’s famous ‘Two Nations Speech,’ a concise indictment of racial-economic inequality that was heard around the world. According to Mbeki, It would take a long time for this divide, a 350 years’ legacy of ‘inequality,’ to be obliterated and allow SA to evolve the requisite psychological cement to form a bona fide nation. Until then, talk of a rainbow nation was a dream deferred. And a dream deferred simmers into explosive rage which, ultimately, explodes. Had Mbeki foreseen the 2012 Marikana Massacre where 34 miners were gunned down by police in broad daylight? Mbeki’s Two-Nations Speech did not delve into systematic details on how SA should proceed to change the status quo other than appeal to the privileged but unresponsive whites to accept the burden of uplifting the disinherited fellow citizens. However, it inspired younger generation of thinkers to start articulating their views on how to move the country forward economically toward a more just and equitable SA. Thus far, the youth are speaking out without fear or favor. After all, they have had minimal stake in the economic status quo. One perspective was articulated in South Africa’s black national newspaper, the Sunday Independent, of September 16, 2012. A young man noted that the country’s economy is a product of two nationalisms: British and Afrikaner. But contemporary SA is composed of three nationalisms. Economically, African nationalism is not reflected among the economic forces that have shaped the country. As a group, Black South Africans, the majority, are still sidelined as economic actors. They are an economically marginalized underclass in their own country. According to the author of that article, South Africa’s socio-economic lopsidedness has resulted from the country’s history. In a nutshell, the British molded the SA economy through their colonialism. Next, the Afrikaners used apartheid in conjunction with their “aggressive affirmative action program for Afrikaners” to entrench their presence in the country’s economy. Yet, after two decades of political independence, Black Africans are still waiting in the wings for their turn to have an economic impact. In SA, British imperial appetite was whetted by the discovery of minerals with which the country is generously endowed. Britain had much to gain from precious metals; they were highly lucrative in the global economy of that era. Accordingly, the British constructed a sophisticated infrastructure to ensure a smooth flow of those exports to the motherland. Indeed since the days of Cecil Rhodes, South Africa has had a comparatively more solid economic infrastructure than the rest of the continent. But SA also inherited another damning legacy from the British imperial order. Proclamation 14 of August 1875 reduced indigenous Africans to a source of cheap labor supply while excluding them from ownership in the mining industry. For the first time, the Proclamation introduced institutional racism into the SA political-economy. Was Marikana Massacre of August 2012 an ugly reflection of the British legacy in the country’s economy? On the other hand, the 1835 Great Trek and eventual establishment of the Transvaal consolidated the formation of the Afrikaner nationalism. The Afrikaners quickly realized that there was no ‘External Angel’ to bail them out; ‘they were in it alone’ and embraced a laager mentality of self-reliance. To this end, they built an industrial complex to address the issue of unemployment among their poor whites. Here too, blacks fitted neatly into a scheme of cheap labor source in Afrikaner-led industry and agriculture.   [caption id="attachment_7892" align="alignright" width="240"]Prof-James-Kariuki Prof-James-Kariuki[/caption] The logic continues that implementation of apartheid in 1948 and after was merely an intensification and general implementation of what the Afrikaner had learned, perhaps too well, from Cecil Rhodes and his associates in the British mining industry. In addition to intensification, apartheid extended the scope of the racial policies, policies that virtually marginalized black folk from the mainstream of the money economy altogether. And, with all its appalling dimensions, apartheid was not oppression by a foreign intruder in the colonial sense. It was a home-grown Afrikaner scheme, and the Afrikaner considered himself an African beyond the indigenous African. To African nationalism of the ANC orientation, the Afrikaner was a permanent challenge because he was born in SA; he was there to stay. In sum, British nationalism historically ‘hogged’ mining in SA as their turf; Afrikaner nationalism arrogated itself other industries and agriculture. The commanding heights of the SA economy were thus partitioned among the whites in such a manner that they thrived on unconscionable exploitation of black folk. In 1994, Black Nationalism finally forced democracy into the SA body politic, affirming the claim that “all men are created equal.” But abolition of political apartheid was not accompanied by demolition of economic apartheid. Yet, alas, does political power alone bestow equality among ‘men’? By all indications, Black Nationalism required penetration into the economic domain to realize full equality. And it should not be an insurmountable undertaking to fulfill Nkrumah’s dictum of ‘Seek ye the political kingdom first and the rest shall be added unto it.’ After all, in the post-1994 era, blacks have had the strength to make decisions favorable to themselves derived from a combination of numbers and associated political muscle. The question is then raised: what decisions have been made to transform the SA economy by successive black ANC governments to consolidate the 1994 political achievement of Black Nationalism? To the current black intellectuals who have spoken out, no new industrial enterprises have emerged under black stewardship since attainment of black political supremacy. In this sense, the post-1994 black governments have failed by neglecting to position their black constituency as a major economic force that it should be. Instead of pursuing the line of greater economic production, it is said, SA has engaged in a superficial scheme of capitalistic massage. White-owned businesses have co-opted a handful of politically well-connected Blacks to become integral part of their business establishments. These ‘inductees’ have become loyal political fronts, protectors of the old businesses from contemporary threats. That is Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) personified. On the other hand, the Government utilizes social grants to placate the huge marginalized underclass of blacks in an environment where unemployment is estimated to be between 25 and 45 percent.  Social grants do not generate jobs and they do not make social services. Political economist, Moeletsi Mbeki views BEE as nothing less than legalized bribery. He is also convinced that SA is de-industrializing and increasingly sliding towards becoming a welfare state. In his view, the country needs to diversify its economy (from mining), encourage growth of black productive class of entrepreneurs, and advance knowledge in “sciences, math, engineering and management education.” “Without that…, we are going nowhere.”  What do these and other contemporary thinkers have in common? Overall, they accept that Blacks are responsible for the country’s sluggish economic growth. In terms of action, they are driven by an ambition to face squarely SA overriding problems of poverty, crime, inequality and unemployment. Overall, they agree that SA must embark on an economic transformation in which a black industrial class figures prominently. In sum their views are that the SA economy, and corresponding political stability, must be anchored on blacks engaging in creation of wealth. **James N. Kariuki is Professor of International Relations (Emeritus) and an independent writer.  He is based in South Africa. Views expressed in the blog Global Africa are his.    ]]>

Share This Article
LinkedIn Email Copy Link Print
Previous Article Intellectuals & South Africa’s Quest for Economic Transformation
Next Article Schizophrenia As Mandela’s Final Caution
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your Trusted Source for Accurate and Timely Updates!

Our commitment to accuracy, impartiality, and delivering breaking news as it happens has earned us the trust of a vast audience. Stay ahead with real-time updates on the latest events, trends.
FacebookLike
XFollow
InstagramFollow
LinkedInFollow
Diestmann

You Might Also Like

AlgeriaAngolaBenin

U.S.-Nigeria Strategic Energy Dialogue Sets a New Stage for Bilateral Cooperation

By
Pan African Visions
Business in AfricaCorperate InsightsEditorial

Tanzania’s Packaging Industry Takes Off as TISEZA Backs Sh6 Billion Factory

By
Pan African Visions
AlgeriaAngolaBenin

Nigeria: FG pledges support to Gambian Armed Forces

By
Pan African Visions
AlgeriaAngolaBenin

Succession In Cameroon: The Rise of Frank Biya Raising Eyebrows

By
Pan African Visions
PAN AFRICAN VISIONS
Facebook Twitter Youtube Rss Medium

About US


Pan African Visions: Your instant connection to breaking stories and live updates. Stay informed with our real-time coverage across politics, tech, entertainment, and more. Your reliable source for 24/7 news.

  • 7614 Green Willow Court, Hyattsville, MD 20785 , USA
  • +1 24 0429 2177
  • pav@panafricanvisions.com
Top Categories
  • Politics
  • Business in Africa
  • Blog
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Multimedia
  • Contact
Usefull Links
  • PAV – Home
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Complaint
  • Advertise With Us

© 2026 Pan African Visions. 
All Rights Reserved.