Dr Cresencia Nyathi and Vedhan Singh*
As South Africa commemorates Women’s Month in August 2025, the country reverberates with a clarion call to celebrate the resilience and contributions of women while confronting the systemic oppressions that undermine their dignity. Yet, for migrant and refugee women in South Africa, this celebration rings hollow; it hauntingly echoes the state’s failures in government health institutions masked behind the veneer of pseudo national protectionism at certain public hospitals and clinics. On one hand, many foreign African doctors are oft sought for their specific super specialty medical skill. On the other hand, foreign African patients in general and women and girls in particular, are subjected to degradation leading to dejection, and demonization leading to disenfranchisement; as they are met with outright health denialism and are stopped, prevented and chased away from accessing healthcare, medicine or medical care in certain South African state health institutions.
Across the country, public hospitals and clinics, intended as sanctuaries of care and healing, are becoming battlegrounds of discrimination and exclusion where groups like Operation Dudula, ActionSA and the “March and March” movement block the entry of migrants and refugees from accessing healthcare by demanding South African identity documents. The institution’s security services personnel at the healthcare institution look on, arguably obfuscating this confusion. These aforementioned groups’ actions, rooted in xenophobia, pregnant with anti-African rhetoric and motivated by a misguided false nationalism, not only violate South Africa’s Constitution but give birth to a betrayal of the feminist principles of equity and justice, care and compassion, empathy and unity that womanhood teaches humanity to embody. Yet it is women who lead these vigilante groups, Black women. Drawing on reports from various civil society organizations and recent media, we argue that the denial of healthcare to migrants, particularly women, is unconstitutional, illegal, and a human rights crisis that demand urgent action to restore Ubuntu, uphold constitutional guarantees and South Africa’s commitment to Pan-Africanism.
Juxtaposedly, as a point of departure, in 1956, women protested against Pass Laws. On the cusp of the 70th anniversary of this epoch-making march, the application of Pass Laws has seemingly come full circle. As if to bring back apartheid, resurrect and reenact Pass Laws and nullify the nation-shaping outcomes of the 1956 Women’s March to the Union Buildings – today women are once again called upon to present their identity documents when moving around, yet this time it is to access health institutions. The non-possession and/or absence of a South African identity document means non-entry into the hospital or clinic. This action is a clear infringement of the right to freedom of movement set out in the South African Constitution.
A constitutional betrayal
South Africa’s Constitution, Section 27(1)(a), Section 27(2), and Section 27(3), guarantee everyone the right to healthcare services, regardless of nationality or documentation status. The Constitutional Court affirmed this right in cases like Government of RSA and Others v Grootboom and Others 2001 and E N and Others v Government of RSA and Others 2007. The National Health Act (No. 61 of 2003) and the Refugees Act (No. 130 of 1998) mandate equitable care for all, including refugees and undocumented migrants. The National Department of Health states that refugees and asylum seekers should be assessed according to the current means test when accessing public healthcare. The 2023 Gauteng High Court ruling further affirmed this right, particularly for pregnant women and children under six, declaring restrictions on their access unlawful. Despite these legal standards, grassroots campaigns like Operation Dudula and “March and March” flout them, blocking migrants at facilities like Addington Hospital in Durban, Kalafong Hospital in Pretoria, and Hillbrow Community Health Centre in Johannesburg.

“This constitutional provision means that all people in South Africa regardless of nationality, legal status, race, gender, age, income level, or geographic location are entitled to access basic healthcare services,” South African Human Rights Commission.
Migrant women face devastating human costs, exemplified by the tragic suicide of a refugee mother at Tygerberg Hospital in Cape Town, leaving behind three young sons, including a newborn. This tragedy highlights “medical xenophobia,” a systemic failure where migrant women are treated as disposable. Pregnant migrant women in Gauteng and Limpopo face denial of critical prenatal care, leading to preventable complications. Reports indicate that undocumented women avoid clinics due to fear of harassment and arrest, further exacerbating health risks. Hospitals like Addington face blockades where self-appointed gatekeepers profile patients based on nationality, skin color, appearance, or language, accusing them of “overburdening” the system.
“Everyone has the right to emergency and primary care,” National Department of Health Spokesperson, Foster Mohale.
The roots of xenophobic exclusion
Community-led campaigns like “March and March” stem from socio-economic frustration, exclusionary nationalism, and political opportunism. South Africa’s high unemployment, underfunded healthcare, and systemic failures like overcrowded clinics and long waiting times create discontent. Migrants, especially Black Africans, are scapegoated for these issues. Historical precedents like the 2008 xenophobic attacks, fueled by economic competition and service delivery failures, echo these sentiments. Today, groups like Operation Dudula exploit these grievances, portraying migrants as threats to “South Africans First” while ignoring their economic contributions.
“I faced something that no human being should experience. Even pregnant women are being turned away. It’s a matter of life or death. I am diabetic and rely on medication. I cannot afford private care. We are just waiting to die,” reflected Christian Tchizungu Kwigomba from the Democratic Republic of the Congo after being turned away with his infants at Addington Hospital.
Social media, especially X, amplifies the narrative of “March and March” excluding migrants and portraying them as perpetual outsiders. This rhetoric, echoed by certain political leaders during their 2024 election campaign, diverts attention from government mismanagement and corruption. The Gauteng Township Economic Development Bill and draft National Labor Migration Policy further legitimize anti-migrant sentiment. The government’s ineffective implementation of the National Action Plan to Combat Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance (2019) signals tacit tolerance, enabling vigilante groups to operate brazenly.
Debunking myths and misinformation
The perception that undocumented migrants overburden healthcare is a pervasive myth that fuels discrimination. Contrary to claims on X and by groups like Operation Dudula, migrants constitute a small fraction of healthcare users. Scalabrini’s research shows that they contribute economically, offsetting their service usage. The real strain stems from systemic issues mentioned above. Therefore, denying migrants care harms public health, as untreated diseases like tuberculosis spread across communities. Another myth is that only citizens deserve public healthcare. This contradicts Section 27’s inclusive mandate and the 1951 Refugee Convention, which protects migrants’ access to essential services. The narrative of African migrants as “health tourists” ignores their barriers to care, including fear of deportation. Excluding migrants does not alleviate healthcare strain, it exacerbates inequities as seen in cases of children with sickle cell anemia or premature infants denied treatment at Addington Hospital.
A feminist imperative for Women’s Month
Women’s Month demands a feminist lens that centers marginalized women. Migrant women face gender, nationality, and economic precarity, making them vulnerable. The Tygerberg tragedy shows how xenophobia exacerbates gender-based vulnerabilities. Kopanang’s reports of denied prenatal care and Scalabrini’s findings on untreated chronic conditions highlight a healthcare system failing its duty. A feminist approach, as advocated by Tusimame Wanawake, requires dismantling xenophobia and patriarchy to ensure all women the right to health, dignity, and life. This approach is necessary as the systemic discrimination that continues to marginalize foreign African women is deeply troubling. It is shocking to see Black South African women leading the charge on the ground by accosting, attacking and confronting other Black African woman without identifying or even grasping their lived experiences as a foreign African woman navigating even more entrenched systems of exclusion than the Black South African woman experience.
A call to action
- Law enforcement and health authorities must act decisively. The South African Police Service (SAPS) should disperse vigilante groups, arrest those engaging in intimidation, and deploy officers to high-risk facilities such as Addington and Kalafong, as mandated by the 2023 Gauteng High Court ruling. We acknowledge that at one of the vigilante groups’ blockages at a Gauteng Clinic, Gauteng SAPS removed the volunteers who were blocking the gate. Based on this principle, KwaZulu-Natal SAPS must follow suit by descending onto public health facilities where these groups present themselves to disperse them through Public Order Policing.
“If people at the hospital complain, or South Africans or immigrants who are stopped at the entrances, we will go. Whoever comes to us, we will respond,” Gauteng SAPS spokesperson Lieutenant Colonel Mavela Masondo
- The Department of Health must issue clear directives reinforcing universal healthcare access, conduct audits to address “medical xenophobia,” and train staff on constitutional rights and cultural sensitivity.
The actions of these movements are “Unlawful acts of vigilantism. No member of the public or structure has the legal or moral authority to block others from accessing healthcare,” KwaZulu-Natal Provincial MEC for Health, Nomagugu Simelane Mngadi.
- Civil society, including feminist organizations, faith-based groups, and medical professionals, must amplify advocacy. In addition, the government must address root causes, underfunding, corruption, and policy gaps, while countering misinformation through campaigns that celebrate migrants’ contributions and Ubuntu.
- The denial of healthcare to migrants is a betrayal of South Africa’s constitutional promise and the spirit of Women’s Month. It undermines Ubuntu, strains regional relations, and erodes the nation’s human rights legacy. This August, let us demand accountability: investigate incidents like Tygerberg, enforce universal healthcare access, condemn xenophobic groups, and fund a healthcare system that serves all. Silence is complicity. By embracing a feminist, inclusive vision, South Africa can honor its democratic ideals and ensure no woman, citizen or migrant, is left behind.
*Dr Cresencia Nyathi (PhD Peacebuilding) is a human rights specialist focusing on community conflict mediation and social cohesion.
Vedhan Singh is an independent governance, peace and security expert.